First one showed up yesterday. I put some sliced apple on the ground below (about 30 feet down) and more and more arrived.

I don't usually see many robins because my deck is about 30 feet up and they are ground feeders. After this visit today I now know that I should be happy I haven't seen many: https://talesfromawanderingalbatross.com/2017/10/10/the-american-robin-my-least-favorite-bird/